SECOND SURFACE
A poem about identity and cognitive change, and the unsettling experience of feeling separated from a former version of yourself.
POETRY
Cassi Sullivan


People say mirrors don’t lie.
Mine hands me a girl
I recognize
but cannot reach.
She leans into the day
without the pieces I can’t find.
She moves through the morning
like a tenant with my keys.
The glass can’t keep her together.
Noise enters like a thrown chair.
A locker slams three hallways away
and my nerves scatter,
papers lifted into air,
no desk to catch them.
I reach for a word and come back
holding its outline.
I start explaining something
and loop—
again,
again—
watching it circle back.
Then I contradict it.
Then I apologize.
Then I can’t remember which version
was meant to be true.
The mirror admires my consistency.
I place my hands on the counter
to make sure they are still assigned to me.
They stay.
But they feel subcontracted.
Lupus did not bruise the surface.
It went for authorship.
Since the diagnosis,
my thoughts arrive translated
from a language
I once spoke fluently.
Details refuse the light.
Everything stands far away,
waving from the big picture.
In math, numbers wander off mid-problem.
In Spanish, the accents lift like birds
I forgot to cage.
Sentences leave carrying holes.
I used to be precise.
Now I am approximate.
I drop things I am still holding.
I forget mid-remembering—
I enter rooms already unsure
what testimony I meant to give.
Behind my eyes, the word lupus
works quietly,
a clerk pulling files.
Keep the face.
Remove the continuity.
My emotions have thinned.
Sadness remains,
dense and available,
sitting in every chair.
I try to feel like myself
and touch interference.
The girl in the mirror
could be trusted with a future.
She looks capable of nuance,
of follow-through,
of finishing her own thoughts.
I watch her with the homesickness of still being here.
Because I remember living there—
in a mind that held detail,
in a body that did not interrupt,
in a self that did not require retrieval.
Somewhere between lab results
and voices padded for impact,
I shifted half an inch to the side.
Everyone kept talking to the version
who remained.
Now I perform her daily.
I am applauded for it.
I fail inside the sound of their hands.
At night, I lie awake
trying to locate the original,
combing back through conversations,
through mistakes,
through the echo of my own repetitions,
waiting for her to step forward
and recognize the body.
The mirror, faithful bureaucrat,
hands me my face.
I take it.
I go out.
I try not to lose it before noon.
(2026/2027: Poem)


